Since when?

I agree with you, but there is such a thing as the growth of the growth, not just the growth.

Even without using AP?

One example is the recent immigration to NY. Because Republicans are against immigration generally, liberals thought they were for it, until recently when the influx became too much, and they realized maybe the Republicans were right after all.

I’ve also found the reverse. Liberals tend to hate whatever republicans like.

As a Jew, you’re watering down the term massively, ultimately resulting in making a real genocide look like a walk in the park. Don’t do that.