• 0 Posts
  • 619 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 3rd, 2023

help-circle

  • It’s not exactly what you mean, but merely mentioning abstinence evokes abstinence educators in the US for me. Abstinence education is bullshit. What kid needs to be told the only way to avoid STDs is to not have sex? Anyone with a functioning brain knows that. Abstinence educators are by and large Christian fundamentalists who go to schools to lie about sex and try to scare kids out of it.

    Somehow I attended a public school which had one of these “educators” come by and preach about the purity of abstinence to my entire class. It was surreal and insulting to our intelligence.










  • I would describe 100 people shitting themselves and throwing up as carnage lol. It’s not the same carnage left by a warzone, or the carnage left in the wake of a black friday sale, or the carnage that happens in a 10 car pileup.

    You can take issue with “slammed” being overused or “carnage” being too flashy or something, but to say it amounts to malpractice and is a result of stupidity or low standards is not really fair imo. People use metaphorical language and hyperbole. It’s fine and normal

    Also, I linked another article using carnage “incorrectly” and I thought that is what you were referring to. The writing quality is fine so I was not sure why you said it was low


  • This is a “get off my lawn” take. The language is not degenerating, it is evolving, as it always has and always will while people whine about kids these days and the way they speak. They quoted a student who correctly and metaphorically described the scene as carnage. This isn’t even a good example of “butchering” the English language – again, it’s just hyperbole.

    Is slang “butchering” the language? Acronyms, initialisms? What about pidgin or creole?

    e: I can almost promise you didn’t read that “poorly written” article, you just didn’t like the quote. It was found by reading the dictionary


  • Nobody thinks people are getting literally “slammed” when it’s in an article title. Have you ever used or seen “decimated” to mean something other than “Every 10th man in a roman cohort was executed”? It’s hyperbole, metaphor, a play on words.

    Here’s an article not describing mass death, but uses “carnage,” as cited by Merriam Webster in their online definition for “carnage,” emphasis mine:

    In practice, Argentinian Cami Nogueira did take a heavy slam that resulted in a concussion and broken nose, and doctors advised her not to keep riding while she recovered.
    But some level of carnage is typical amongst the men that compete at Rampage, too. The reigning champion, Cam Zink, was evacuated by helicopter  with broken ribs and a punctured lung after crashing during the men’s competition on Saturday.

    https://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-adventure/biking/redbull-rampage-recap-2024-women/

    Carnage can mean any sort of chaos or harm coming to a group of people. I don’t see the use in pedantically hating on colorful language or simple literary devices.