Thanks everyone for the help.
Original post: I want to create a niche community, but considering Lemmy can’t see kbin magazines, wouldn’t it make more sense to make the community on Lemmy, that way people from both Lemmy and kbin can be a part if it?
Maybe I should have posted this on a nostupidquestions community, I don’t know.
Lemmy can see kbin magazines. I’m on a lemmy instance right now.
kbin.social itself has had some federation issues in the past month, but I think that’s more growing pains of a new platform than anything inherent in the system itself.
Oh, maybe that’s where I got the idea that Lemmy couldn’t see them, I’ve only been on the fediverse for a couple weeks. People were saying Lemmy couldn’t see kbin, but I didn’t realize that was temporary.
Not really suspicion at this point. They are proveably 403 rejecting requests from the KBin useragent. You have the letters “kbinbot” anywhere in your useragent (case insensitive) you ain’t getting content.
As a bonus they’re still sending out stuff to instances though. But since KBin can’t then resolve it it amounts to a DoS attack as the messages just build up in KBin retry queues.
At what point do the other instances consider this federation in bad faith and defederate from .ml?
A number of kbin instances already have. But not .social - which is obviously the largest instance.
Aggravatingly .ml users can browse and interact with kbin magazines just fine as we let them in. It’s very much a bad faith thing at this point.
Noted and I’ll make sure that my list is clear of .ml subs. Honestly, with the “not so much rumors as facts” information swirling around out there about the devs, I’ll not be surprised if they’re intentionally tanking (pun intended) any competition that isn’t parroting their views.
G’day from a Kbinaut :)
deleted by creator
Yeah this seems to be a temporary thing. I’ve been following the federation issues we’ve been having on kbin and I’m hoping they can resolved as everything stabilizes.
I’m unsure if the ingest from kbin > Lemmy was working because last I checked they were returning error responses on requests that had “kbinbot” in the name.
I’m unsure if the ingest from kbin > Lemmy was working because last I checked they were returning error responses on requests that had “kbinbot” in the name.
It’s only lemmy.ml, not all of lemmy, that’s returning a forbidden response on requests from kbin.
There definitely seems to be something going on but I haven’t found solid problem replication steps.
For example it may be because the instance the thread was posted on is lemmy.ml but I expected the thread here: https://kbin.social/m/asklemmy@lemmy.ml/t/163712/former-current-Twitter-users-what-do-you-do-on-there would still sync up with where the version of the thread where the OP is located https://lemmy.nz/post/314511 even if it the instance where the thread was posted (maybe?) doesn’t federate with kbin.social: https://lemmy.ml/post/1868037
It’s possible my mental model of fediverse working is just still very basic and thread instance is the ultimate arbiter?
Yeah that doesn’t look like it’s federation correctly. I’ll raise it again with some of the other devs, maybe one of them will know. Pretty annoying ;(
I hope kbin gets federated by lemmy.ml it seems they have been rather trigger happy with blocking. It seems we will have to wait and see which instance is the most free.
A lot of the original Lemmy instances are quite trigger happy. It’s one really nice thing about the new instances with new admins who block but still prefer not to unless it’s really necessary.
i kind of knew what i was signing up for with this lemmy ecosystem, so at worst people will just switch instances and the most free gain the most leverage, it beats this hopping from one centralized service to another by far.
I’ve been all-in on the fediverse since early 2021, including the threadiverse. It may not be the future for the masses, but I think it might be the future for people who value freedom and autonomy.
there are like 10 times or 20 times more users online than back when reddit even started, i think we will be fine even if it wont be for “the masses”. I respect that you got in early, a true pioneer.
Lemmy can see kbin magazines. I am posting this from Lemmy!
Caveat: Magazines, just like lemmy communities from other instances/servers are not there by default. Users or admins have to seek them out.
Well I feel stupid, is this new that Lemmy can see magazines? Originally could they not?
Don’t. I think it was broken.
No it’s not new, that’s the whole idea of the fediverse.
There has been some technical issues but they should just share all content.
When I joined I could, then I think maybe federation was wonky for a bit there, but it seems to be all good now.
(hi from lemmy)
Yeah, kbin is only something like a month old and our dev did NOT expect the influx that he got. He knew about the stuff at reddit, but thought since lemmy was both older and everyone’s first mention, he might get a few.
Nah. Thousands in a matter of days. He had to turn cloudflare on for a few days, which would break the ability to federate but would also keep the server from certain doom while he scrambled to upgrade things. Guy’s got my sheepish respect.
So that’s the majority of why we went dark on you guys, but it feels like we’re going pretty good now. Still working things out, and from what I hear there are also issues on lemmy’s side — bugs in the default config/in 0.18.0, lemmy.ml specifically and possibly deliberately blocking outgoing kbin info — that are adding additional difficulty between us.
Especially with lemmy.ml. It seems to have gotten a fuckton of communities I would have been super interested in, but until the devs decide to unblock kbin.bot, nothing I interact with on .ml will reach back to them, nor would any of our own posts/communities. It’s functioning like a noncommittal softblock, and since the instance ignoring our entire platform seems to be a giant one, it’s damaging.
Hi back from kbin, though :)
I have no problems not being able to interact with the overt tankie instance tbh
Thanks for the details. I’m on kbin too but I’m a sucker for an app so lemmy sunk my time. Looking forward to the day I’m using Sync for both platforms.
I do get that, especially when the overall reason for all this was the apps. And of course we don’t really even have an API atm in order to churn them out at the pace Lemmy is. I only know of Artemis for kbin, although I’m aching to try it when it’s done
The API is on its way though, I’ve only got a few more endpoints and permissions to add before it will be ready for testing
But how did we get here? On kbin trying to search for a Lemmy community I can’t find it, and on Lemmy looking for kbin the same happens. And yet here we are because someone figured out how to find it and subscribe.
Those kinds of things are slowly being ironed out, I believe.
If nobody has ever subscribed to a foreign instance’s community/magazine before, it won’t show up on your home instance. Currently, the best way to pull it into your local instance is to copy its web address on the other site into your local search.
e.g. If you wanted to pull in
kbin.social’s AskKbin fromlemmy.worldyou’d find its URL,https://kbin.social/m/AskKbin, and paste that address into your home instance’s search box. As long as somebody has done this once, AskKbin will now show up in regular community lists, searches, etc.
what’s the difference between a kbin magazine and a community?
It’s mostly the same, but magazines also include hashtags from microblogs like mastodon.
Nothing really, they just use different names for the same thing. Like how Reddit has subreddits.
oh interesting
if this was posted to a kbin magazine I’m here viewing it from a Lemmy instance
It was, and your post is currently visible in the AskKbin magazine / community / subreddit / group thing as well as on Lemmy.
You can see it in your normal web browser via the main kbin instance with the link https://kbin.social/m/AskKbin/t/168071/Would-it-not-make-more-sense-to-create-a-community
Same thing, just different terms.
OP could you edit your title with an accurate statement? Like: TIL it doesn’t matter if you make your community on Lemmy or kbin, they’re federated and will have equal exposure
That way people will get the right impression even without going to the comments :)
(btw I downvoted your post for now but I upvoted a comment because I felt bad about taking away your karma for asking a totally reasonable question)
Will do. I’ll use your title suggestion as it’s early in the morning and I don’t want to think for myself :p
Thanks a lot! I’m so glad title editing exists here
deleted by creator
lemmy users can see kbin magazines but kbin magazines are a bit less discoverable since lemmy in particular has tools to help with finding cross-instance communities. I don’t really like lemmy so I didn’t bother making my more niche groups lemmy-specific.
It honestly depends on how centralized you want to be. Do we want all communities on the largest lemmy instance or do we want them on many different instances, some of which are kbin? Suppose there’s a security hole in Lemmy code that needs to be updated. It’d be good for some of the communities to be on Kbin while that’s being fixed, and vice versa.
But really, kbin and lemmy have small but essential differences. I adore the kbin integration with Mastodon and it’s hashtags, so I’m going to prefer a kbin server with that for any communities I make. They can still be found. They can still hit the front page if they get a good thread going. They still show up in the newest feed.
Lemmy.world recent incident was a great demonstration of the benefit there is to spreading what instances communities are created on. There was some grumbling about /r/Android coming and making their own instance and then lemmy.world/c/Android merging with them there, but turns out it’s good to not have all the eggs in one basket.
I’m on lemmy and looking at your post.
you’ll get exposed alright
