Your personal feel towards them, let’s try not to judge too much. Mine is Alan Shearer, while a PL legend I think people like to fit him in with actual world class strikers…feel like he was good, but played in a very weak PL era. Might be top 2 in the PL but very far behind if we consider the world
Dembele (Barca/psg)
I feel people love him so much because they use him on Fifa. I watched Barca games all the time, he has never done anything amazing. Can not finish in the box at all.
On his day he’s a world class RW, but injury prone and inconsistent
Clearly an arsenal fan still salty about losing.
Blazingly hot takes here: Ibra and Lewandowsky. Their performances in crucial Champions league moments are from wank to subpar.
People usually quote Lewan’s 4 goals against Real when he was at Bvb to argue that Lewan is a big game player, as if he retired from CL since then. Where was him when Bayern had to struggle against Barca, Real, Atl and Liv ? Does he have any memorable semifinal or final where he is the biggest star ?
There is even less to talk about with Ibra’s record in CL given his longevity in many top European teams.
Widely regarded as best strikers of the game, they are rightly expected to provide when their team most need them. But they failed at those times.
Brave take, I understand your reasoning though…but where you rate players like Benzema, not as consistent as those guys but has higher highs
I rate Benzema higher than Lewy, Ibra. He had been wonderful since CR7 left, especially in CL knockouts.
But even when they played together, Benzema’s role is to support. So it doesn’t matter if Karim is silent when Ronaldo can score which is sth he does almost every match.
Alan Shearer played in a weak PL era? The late 90’s early 00’s was a weak era? Shearer is underrated for me, the man could score in a nunnery and has the record for PL goals whilst spending half his career in a shit Newcastle team, a couple seasons in the first division, and have 2 season long injuries.
I feel like its purely a younger generation thing to say Shearer wasn’t brilliant, he played and captained England in a generation with Fowler, Sherringham, Ferdinand, Cole, Owen.
Willian. anyone know where he is now???
Mason Mount, he’s not terrible but overrated by a lot of pundits imo.
Mount is an enigma, I think he is a pretty good player that is excellent at implementing what managers want.
So top managers pick him and he does very well for them, but he in and of himself is just a fine prem player. I do think under an elite manager he could be excellent again but that won’t happen now.
This is actually a great answer, it explains what I think of him much better than I can
Chelsea fan seconds this. He only stood out of the pile because he was average among a shitty squad
I know you said not to judge but Shearer being overrated is lunacy. The guys was fast, strong, could head it in, fire from distance, just an all round top baller. I honestly think he would cut it in the modern game and i think you have a bias because he played for newcastle and looked quite ordinary.
For me it’s Rashford. I feel like he had such an explosive start to his career and has never seemed to push on from his potential. A somewhat decent player on his day but imo is no where near the level for international football or playing for a top 4 side
Was coming to say Rashford but take my upvote instead lol but yeah, you’re right. He had an explosive start I remember thinking Man United have found another one but… Yeah. Just seems to only play when he’s feeling it and even then it’s few and far between. Definitely shouldn’t be in a top 4 team.
That’s the thing with him isnt it. For me, there definitely is top 4-6 quality in Rashford yet he is so inconsistent. No one would put him alongside the greats like Rooney, v. Persie, Ronaldo but I still feel he would have a place alongside such players if he would be the only one in his position.
People trash and meme on Rashford a lot in match threads. I don’t think he is overrated.
Op must be 12 years old to mention Shearer.
He went to unfavoured clubs instead of chasing titles at Utd
Good thing my question wasn’t about what you thought about my opinion beloved
Probably Messi, he’s still top 20 players of all time but not the GOAT imo, many players are better than him
Many?
risky opinion damn . You might wanna lock your home tonight mate probably hire a bodyguard.
Sorry, but in all my life watching football. No one has been better than Messi.
List the many players that are better than him. Go on
How to prove you never watched Alan Shearer play without admitting that you never watched Alan Shearer.
Him and R9 were the best CF of the late 1990’s. A big gap admittedly but no shame in it.
I liked that there was a certain viciousness to his style of play.
Is shearer a top 10-15 striker of all time?
Clearly one of the top strikers in English history for sure. Better than Gerd Müller or R9? I don’t think so.
Yeah and that’s my whole point, feel like he gets over rated
If you are one of the best strikers in English football history, you are clearly not overrated.
Kinda hard to say any player who plays at the top level sucks, but overrated? Pique. Definitely not a good enough footballer to have married Shakira and then cheated. Like I’d accept that shit from Maldini or something but not Pique ffs
I’m the biggest Pique hater, especially during the early 2010s, but over time dude has proved to be a class defender
I think Ramos is a great defender, but not near the top defender ever.
He was solid, but had so many mistakes to be regarded as the top defender of all time, and I think his goal scoring abilities (unbelievable for a defender) helped compensate some of his mistakes. But so many times when I watched him, I was like what was he thinking by doing this?
This is a brave take. However I still think Maldini is the Goat, others would even put Baresi before Ramos, but I haven’t seen him play
What? Ramos is a great player but no one but his mother would rate him above Baresi and Maldini. I can think of another half a dozen defenders better than him since I have started watching footy.
I’d argue Shearer scored goals in an era when defenders could do more to stop them. Players are more protected nowadays
Plus he wasn’t scoring those goals for the best teams in the league
Hi /u/Brunos_left_nut, thank you for participating in /r/football. Unfortunately, your submission has been removed for the following reason(s):
- https://www.reddit.com/r/football/comments/16ph90m/important_update_for_rfootball_elevating_content/
If you have any questions about this removal, please feel free to [message the moderators.](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/football&subject=Question regarding the removal of this submission by /u/Brunos_left_nut&message=I have a question regarding the removal of this submission.
Benzema
People forget how bad he was for years. His one great season is all what people remember. You see on this app and others Benzema being put in conversation he doesn’t deserve to be in. He’s absolutely nowhere near the greatest strikers of all time.
Never scored 30 league goals in a season. Only one season he scored more than 25.
Comparing him to Suarez, Lewandowski, Ibrahimovic or even Henry is embarrassing and shows a lack of understanding imo.
I think it should be no doubt Benzema is a tier below Suarez, Lewa, Ibra.
Nothing wrong with that either but RM fans are toxic as hell