Obviously villa

Well, you could strip all the interesting stuff about human intelligence out of humanity, like a Stepford Wives situation, make everyone perfect and ideal for some vision…

Or you can give humans agency and free will, let them have their own thoughts, and it leads to both atrocities, innovation, and other amazing things.

Neither of these scenarios actually proves there is no all good, all seeing, all powerful entity that created the universe, or watches over us, or even created evolution or just snapped us into existence. If it gave us free will, we and we alone are responsible for the atrocities we commit