So a post came across my FB of “cut 1 at there peak” and it was:
Westbrook Rose Paul Nash
and im goin thru the comments and the majority is saying chris paul. Like am i wearing rose tinted glasses or are people just not putting respect on the point god
Btw if i had to rank them i got: 1nash 2 paul 3 Westbrook 4 rose…and this hurts me as a D-rose fan and from Chicago but honestly them injures really killed him at his peak
I take New Orleans CP3 over any version of the other 3.
08-10 CP3
05-07 Nash
MVP Russ
MVP Rose
You are asking at their absolute prime. You can’t take injuries it to account.
Also everyone on this list won MVP except Chris Paul
I’d still take Chris Paul over Derrick Rose. We won’t know how great D Rose could’ve been, he was definitely going to get better as he aged into his prime until he got injured.
Don’t take basketball opinions from a bunch of retirees and housewives. I don’t know anyone else that uses Facebook.
I’m going with this being an incredibly stupid question on a forum that pulls the lowest common denominators.
You’d happily have all 4 of them and your decision would almost certainly be based on how you envision basketball so feel free to hate on one all timer so First take can write some material without having to pay for writers.
I think you’re confusing overall career vs. peak.
I mean if you’re comparing dudes at their peak, they all were MVPs at some point. So pretty obviously cp3 here.
If you just wanna make an all time list D-Rose is certainly at the bottom
Again as a die hard Rose fan this hurts but as a realists this is true. Health DRose could of been one of the greats
You can’t compare mvp’s across different years to see who is better. One not having mvp doesn’t mean he was the worst at his peak.