This fall, The Marvels take flight.Carol Danvers aka Captain Marvel has reclaimed her identity from the tyrannical Kree and taken revenge on the Supreme Inte...
Captain Marvel may be an unsalvageable character at this point. Her origin movie was for badly handled by the writers.
The problem with the character is that she never earned her powers. There was never any struggle. Never any challenges she had to overcome by growing as a person. In her first movie she was just magically good at everything all the time, always.
I suppose they could give her the Thor treatment… Totally take away all her powers until she proved herself worthy… Have her fail and grow.
Captain Marvel in the comics explicitly never earns her powers either.
But then again, neither does Superman over in DC. Captain Marvel is basically a Superman analog (as are Sentry and Hyperion, really, but they’re not in the MCU yet)
Regarding superman… Superman I and II were both part of the same story, and we DO see Superman lost his powers and earn them back.
But even just in Superman I, we see him struggle. When kryptonite takes his powers, it is his past good deeds and his heartfelt plea that gets lex luthors henchwoman to release him. And we see Superman fail and lose Lois lane.
Earlier in the movie we see young Clark scolded and humbled by his father for showing off his powers.
He is a character who fails in small ways and grows. That’s why we empathize with him.
Gonna be real man I don’t think either Superman 1 or 2 were better than the first Captain Marvel movie, and it isn’t close.
Captain Marvel’s entire arc is based on defining who she is and wants to be, not her powers themselves. She’s an amnesiac that was basically kidnapped and turned into a weapon.
Avatar series are the highest and third highest grossing movies of all time, and I don’t think either Avatar movie is that good, either. They’re fine, but I don’t understand how they’re so popular.
Citizen Kane and 2001 are both considered among the greatest films of all time and I don’t like those either. 2001 is only marginally interesting, and Kane just sucks imo.
Turns out people like different things. I enjoy Marvel movies for what they are and this one has me hyped.
Wait, you don’t see Captain Marvel struggling for her powers? What about the entire plot surrounding her being restrained by the kree and having to overcome a planetary computer that’s been manipulating her for years into believing she’s just another kree, is too dangerous to not be held back, and that took her whole-ass identity away isn’t Danvers struggling and earning her powers?
I honestly don’t know if you watched the same movie as me.
That’s really not it. Her orgin movie is handled really well, if you understand the context the Binary storyline was written with. Jude law stands in for the Brood, the Supreme intelligence stands in for Mar-vel.
She didn’t “earn” her powers in the comics. They were thrust on her against her will, while she was under mind control and her friends had abandoned her. Her powers come from a traumatic episode she was put through without her consent, which is very well represented in the movie.
I’d recommend listening to this podcast. It gives you some context around the original comics and will fill in the parts that you’re clearly misunderstanding.
Captain Marvel may be an unsalvageable character at this point. Her origin movie was for badly handled by the writers.
The problem with the character is that she never earned her powers. There was never any struggle. Never any challenges she had to overcome by growing as a person. In her first movie she was just magically good at everything all the time, always.
I suppose they could give her the Thor treatment… Totally take away all her powers until she proved herself worthy… Have her fail and grow.
Captain Marvel in the comics explicitly never earns her powers either.
But then again, neither does Superman over in DC. Captain Marvel is basically a Superman analog (as are Sentry and Hyperion, really, but they’re not in the MCU yet)
Regarding superman… Superman I and II were both part of the same story, and we DO see Superman lost his powers and earn them back.
But even just in Superman I, we see him struggle. When kryptonite takes his powers, it is his past good deeds and his heartfelt plea that gets lex luthors henchwoman to release him. And we see Superman fail and lose Lois lane.
Earlier in the movie we see young Clark scolded and humbled by his father for showing off his powers.
He is a character who fails in small ways and grows. That’s why we empathize with him.
Gonna be real man I don’t think either Superman 1 or 2 were better than the first Captain Marvel movie, and it isn’t close.
Captain Marvel’s entire arc is based on defining who she is and wants to be, not her powers themselves. She’s an amnesiac that was basically kidnapped and turned into a weapon.
The IMDB and metacritic scores show Superman is much more highly regarded by the public and critics alike.
Avatar series are the highest and third highest grossing movies of all time, and I don’t think either Avatar movie is that good, either. They’re fine, but I don’t understand how they’re so popular.
Citizen Kane and 2001 are both considered among the greatest films of all time and I don’t like those either. 2001 is only marginally interesting, and Kane just sucks imo.
Turns out people like different things. I enjoy Marvel movies for what they are and this one has me hyped.
That’s fine. You can argue that your opinion is right and that is the world that’s wrong.
It’s just not a very compelling argument.
I grew up reading fucking comic books dude you don’t need to explain to me that I’m a nerd.
There is no “right” kind of media to enjoy.
Wait, you don’t see Captain Marvel struggling for her powers? What about the entire plot surrounding her being restrained by the kree and having to overcome a planetary computer that’s been manipulating her for years into believing she’s just another kree, is too dangerous to not be held back, and that took her whole-ass identity away isn’t Danvers struggling and earning her powers?
I honestly don’t know if you watched the same movie as me.
That’s really not it. Her orgin movie is handled really well, if you understand the context the Binary storyline was written with. Jude law stands in for the Brood, the Supreme intelligence stands in for Mar-vel.
She didn’t “earn” her powers in the comics. They were thrust on her against her will, while she was under mind control and her friends had abandoned her. Her powers come from a traumatic episode she was put through without her consent, which is very well represented in the movie.
I’d recommend listening to this podcast. It gives you some context around the original comics and will fill in the parts that you’re clearly misunderstanding.
https://open.spotify.com/episode/6HHemzqKHY048gt7KnJfh0?si=czcRDmAhSieNjTCvZlmpxA