Hi there. In these times, folks are becoming more aware on how the social media companies are tracking their activity online, and selling the data for AI training purposes. They’re getting tired of being sold to third parties as a product, instead of being the customers or users of these platforms.

Sadly, Mastodon is losing its chance to become a real alternative to this business model. Why? Because the majority of users, me included, are no less sick and tired of online radical politics, regardless of orientation, being forced 24/7 upon them. They just want a friendly conversation on life, job and hobby topics… and perhaps also opt-in from time to time on the denser subjects of social and political issues. Mastodon claims to be ad-free… but in fact, the majority of contents over there can still be considered political ads disguised as personal takes.

An example: I went to instances.social, picked up spanish language… users and content were just the default. And this was the very first entry coming out:

“Todon.nl is een radicaal linkse anti-autoritaire Mastodonserver. Wij verwelkomen anarchisten, socialisten, (klimaat)activisten, LHBTQIA±personen, milieubewuste mensen, intersectionelen, antiracisten, antifascisten, antikapitalisten, veganisten, piraten, mensenrechtenactivisten, enz. Als ze maar radicaal, links én anti-autoritair zijn”.

The default instance on most of the Mastodon apps for the phone, is equally focused on radical politics in the feed, and its not reflective of the interests of the general public as a whole, but rather alienating. This is a boon to Zuckerberg and Musk… not to the majority of users, open source, or internet privacy. It is not surprising, given this fact, that Mastodon moderators have repeatedly tended to ban the users for the most perplexing reasons (likely because of not being politically radical enough). Regardless, not the way an alternative to the mainstream social media should ever be.

Everybody should be able to enjoy a conversation in a wide array of controversial topics if they desire to, but users should be able to opt-in, not being forced-in. Unless this changes, so that Mastodon becomes a truly welcoming site (even for the people who’re sick of ideology being fed into their throats, which are many), there’s no chance for it to become the alternative to commercial social media that it aims to be.

  • comediatriste@alien.topOPBEnglish
    1·
    1 year ago

    No. When you pick up the default or official instance from the phone app, you expect a bit of everything but not, in any case, a political room. Why was I directed to a radical Mastodon instance in the index? If I changed no settings, just went with the default.

    I have studies in social sciences, talked to sociologists, anthropologists… if this dose of politics on Mastodon is making me gag, I can only imagine the reaction of average people, who will make their minds about it from the first impression and default settings. Sorry, but sometimes less is more.

    • Beardedgeek72@alien.topBEnglish
      1·
      1 year ago

      Because it is one of the most popular ones with your search criteria?

      IT is really not a difficult question.

      ​

      Another issue of course is that people who are used to commercial social media think Mastodon has a “need to take off”. Mastodon did fine with 80 000 total users, it does not need to make a profit. The whole idea of “be popular or die” is such a capitalist concept.