So I’ve had cable Internet for ages. I’ve been through the ringer with them since buying my house many years ago. Intermittent issues that ended up with many many tech visits. It resulted in the wire from pole to my house being replaced, most of the interior coax being replaced, having a powered splitter installed and I’ve been in a great place since then.

I’ve wired my networking around this setup. Main coax comes in the basement near the elec panel and goes directly to my powered splitter in the center of the basement. I have a dedicated coax wire from the powered splitter to the cable modem upstairs. There’s a regular splitter off the powered one which goes to every room. That said, I don’t have cable TV anymore so have abandoned it for the most part. My cable modem goes into a router right next to it which has all 4 ports used. One simply crossed the room to a computer. The others go back into the basement where I have a punch board set up. Two go to punch board and one to a switch. Those route to different rooms wired for cat6. The two dedicated to my basement office come directly from the router through the punch board with no switch. One supports my gaming machine, the other my work setup for WFH days. The office is actually back where the ingress of the house coax and electrical is (my office closet has the main elec panel for the house).

Following?

In amazing timing, no less than two weeks after finishing the basement and doing all this work, I find out fiber is coming. I’ve always wanted fiber over cable but I’m wondering if it’s worth it if everything is working ok for now.

If I were to put it in, I’m assuming most of my setup goes out the window. I’d imagine the fiber drop would be where the elec panel is? Then what, I put the router in the office and wire the two machines directly off the router then use one of my in-wall jacks to get back to the main punch board to connect everything else? But then the router is in the corner of the basement. That’d probably kill my wifi to the rest of the house and the clean in-wall setup for my office will be toast. I’d be back to having two cords running around my office and the second drop in the office is worthless.

Is there an alternative? Could I pass the fiber connection back to the central hub area and put the router there? I don’t have any access to the ceiling anymore as it’s all drywalled. Now I wish I ran 3 or 4 cords to each basement room instead of 2.

What terrible timing. A month earlier and I could have done a lot more to prep for this while the walls were open.

Hope what I said makes sense. I can try to make a picture.

No experience with fiber at all. Just trying to get an idea if this is worthwhile. I suppose I could get a mesh wifi system and use my cat6 as a backhaul as well but that’s expense on top of recently replacing my router anyways. Open to thoughts!

  • Sportiness6@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    1 year ago
    1. fiber is absolutely worthwhile.
    2. In my experience you can have the fiber brought to your hub, but your provider likely isn’t going do that for you. You will need to call them for the Fiber, and then have someone else run it, then call them back to terminate it(again based on experience)
    3. Whether mesh works for you is a decision for you. It doesn’t pay for me, in my environment. I’d have paid 3K for the latest net gear mesh system. When I could invest the same 3K in a much more prosumer system with a top of the line router/switch/AP. But you have to make that decision.