Well this one today for me has to be Monreal. Did a pretty decent job overall. I would have put Clichy but I think he might have just missed the cut off on the dates you are asking for. I had high hopes back in the day for Gibbs but in my opinion he did not become the player I had hoped for.

By the way I’m really quite enjoying this game every day. I’m fact I just sat down with a coffee and starting thinking “I wonder if I missed the game today”. Opened Reddit and this popped up first on my screen 🤣