I have a Synology that needs more storage. Thoughts on WD vs Seagate?

I’ve always bought WD Red, but with the recent WD controversies (including the SMR/CMR scandal and the recent WDDA warning), I’m considering Seagate. Also, I can’t find any difference between the IronWolf Pro and Exos drives. What am I missing?

Metric Seagate IronWolf Pro 20TB Seagate Exos X20 20TB WD Red Pro 20TB
Spindle speed (RPM) 7200 7200 7200
Internal transfer rate 285 MB/s 272 MB/s 268 MB/s
Gas Helium Helium ???
Cache 256MB 256MB 512MB
CMR? Yes Yes Yes
MTBF (hours) 2.5m 2.5m 2.5m
Non-recoverable errors per bits read 1 in 10^15 1 in 10^15 1 in 10^15
Load unload cycles 600k 600k 600k
Workload rate (TB/yr) 550 550 550
Annualized Failure Rate (AFR) 0.35% 0.35% ???
Warranty 5yr 5yr 5yr
Price $349.99 $329.99 $379.99

Also, please don’t recommend shucking (those drives are in external enclosures because they didn’t pass QC to become internal HDDs).

  • Special-Rest1988@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    According to the detailed information that back blaze releases on drive reliability and pricing. Western digitals cost more and are more reliable if you’re keeping the drives for a very long time. If you’re replacing the drives in two to three years with something else go Seagate as Seagate drives fail more often at the 3 to 4 years I think. It’s been a long time since I read the review but if you do a custom Nas with disc shelves. It’s even cheaper if you get a bunch of used Enterprise drives yes they’re going to have a ridiculous amount of hours on them but you put them into a raid 2 or a raid 3 and you pay a little bit more monitoring attention to them but you’ll save a couple extra dollars on those much larger arrays my two cents from what I I’ve read.